Oak dining furniture beside a large window overlooking a quiet Bainbridge Island inlet and wooded shore on a cloudy late-autumn afternoon.

Reading Bainbridge Island's Fall Housing Numbers, Month by Month

Oak dining furniture beside a large window overlooking a quiet Bainbridge Island inlet and wooded shore on a cloudy late-autumn afternoon.

Reading Bainbridge Island's Fall Housing Numbers, Month by Month

In October 2026, the median sale price for homes and condos on Bainbridge Island was $1,399,000. That was 19.67% higher than in October 2025, according to the Northwest Multiple Listing Service's Kitsap County breakout for October. On the same line of that report, pending sales fell from 33 to 20 over the same period, a drop of 39.39%. Active listings rose from 73 to 115.

So prices went up, contracts went down and there were more listings, all in one month. The figures fit together once you separate closings from contracts. A median is calculated from homes that finished closing, and the island's busiest contract month this fall was September. October's contracts were signed in the weeks of the highest mortgage rates in more than a year. If you are comparing Bainbridge Island with other places this winter, the pending count tells you more about the market you will actually buy in than the median does.

Four Months on Map Area 170

NWMLS reports Bainbridge Island as map area 170. Here are the figures for houses and condos combined over the past four months, each compared with the same month of 2025.

Month (2026) New listings Active Pending Closed Median Months of inventory
July 69 vs 52 124 vs 118 38 vs 49 46 vs 38 $1,255,000, down 7.89% 2.70
August 68 vs 45 108 vs 89 57 vs 55 38 vs 43 $1,261,500, down 1.06% 2.84
September 70 vs 39 112 vs 80 41 vs 28 52 vs 41 $1,174,500, up 6.77% 2.15
October 42 vs 44 115 vs 73 20 vs 33 34 vs 29 $1,399,000, up 19.67% 3.38

From July through October, the median went from $1,255,000 to $1,261,500, down to $1,174,500, then up to $1,399,000. A market where true values moved that much from month to month would show it in other ways too. The likelier explanation is a small market. When an area closes 34 to 52 sales a month, a few large waterfront closings or a few small condo closings can move the middle of the list by six figures.

September Was the Contract Month

September was the strongest month for new contracts on the island this fall. Pending sales rose to 41, up 46.43% from 28 in September 2025, and September closings reached 52. October's 34 closings came right after that surge, before the slowdown in contracts had time to show up in the closed column. We read the $1,399,000 October median as a record of a stronger stretch than October itself.

October's own contract activity was much weaker. For every 100 homes newly listed on Bainbridge that month, about 48 went under contract. In October 2025 the figure was about 75. Those ratios come straight from the NWMLS area 170 row, which shows 20 pending against 42 new listings in October 2026 and 33 against 44 a year earlier.

The Five Condos Inside the Median

Splitting October by property type shows how much the mix of homes can move the median. Houses alone had a median of $1,400,000 on 29 closings in October 2026, compared with $1,272,500 on 22 closings in October 2025. That is a 10.02% increase. Condos were a smaller group. Five closed in October 2026 at a median of $1,195,000, compared with seven a year earlier at a median of $678,000.

With five sales in one month and seven in the other, the condo median compares two small, different sets of units. NWMLS gives the same caution in its October market release: medians shift with the mix of homes sold, especially in small segments such as condominiums. Across the whole NWMLS service area, the October condo median fell 13.0% from a year earlier to $435,000, the lowest since February 2023.

Inventory Grew Because Sales Slowed

The island's 57.53% year-over-year rise in active listings in October 2026 could look like a wave of new sellers. The new-listing count says otherwise. Owners listed 42 homes in October, two fewer than in October 2025. Listings piled up because fewer of them sold.

September was different. New listings jumped to 70 that month from 39 a year earlier, and buyers kept up, which is why months of inventory dropped to 2.15. By October the supply was still on the market and buyers had slowed down. Months of inventory rose to 3.38, which puts Bainbridge just above Kitsap County as a whole. The county had 3.23 months of inventory in October and a $590,000 median, down 1.58% from a year earlier.

The regional numbers tell the same story. NWMLS reported that October new listings across its service area were unchanged from a year earlier at 7,991. Buyers went under contract on about 69 homes for every 100 new listings, compared with about 84 in October 2025. Months of inventory reached 4.41, the highest for any October since at least 2014. Bainbridge's drop from about 75 to about 48 per 100 is steeper than the regional drop.

The Rate Peak Fell in October

The timing lines up with mortgage rates. In its November 5 release, NWMLS reported that the average 30-year fixed rate reached 7.40% in the weeks of October 8 and October 15, the highest weekly average in more than a year, citing Freddie Mac. The rate had eased to 7.24% by October 29, compared with 6.17% a year earlier. In the same release, Steven Bourassa, director of the Washington Center for Real Estate Research, said, "Thirty-year mortgage interest rates averaged 7.33% in October versus 6.86% in September, a rise of nearly half a percentage point."

Rates have been falling since then. Freddie Mac's Primary Mortgage Market Survey reported a 30-year fixed average of 7.11% for the week ending November 12, 2026. That was the fourth straight weekly decline and the lowest level in seven weeks, though still above the 6.24% of a year earlier. September's monthly average rate was 6.86%, and October's was 7.33%. That jump is the most likely reason Bainbridge contracts fell in October even with plenty of homes available.

What the Top of September Shows

September's highest sales show what a strong contract month looked like at the top of the island market. Seattle Agent Magazine's ranking of Bainbridge's ten most expensive September sales was led by 10555 NE Seaborn Road near Blakely Harbor at $5,750,000. Our own Mark Middleton listed it together with Jen Cameron of The Agency Seattle/Eastside. Fourth on the list was 10147 NE Roberts Road at $3,050,000, also listed by Mark.

The rest of the list covered much of the island. It included Madrona Drive at $3,750,000, Ridge Lane at $3,300,000, Blue Heron Lane at $3,000,000, Agate Beach Lane at $2,550,000, Arrow Point Loop at $2,500,000 and West Port Madison Road at $2,459,000. The tenth sale on the list closed at $2,405,000. Five of the ten sold for $3 million or more, and every one was above $2.4 million.

A few sales at this level closing in the same window can lift the island median whether or not a typical home on a typical street is worth more. For buyers looking at Port Blakely or Port Madison, what matters is how a property compares with recent sales of similar homes. The island-wide median is not a guide to a single home's value.

What the November and December Numbers Will Show

October's 20 pending sales were the smallest pending count of the four months in the table. A buyer this winter is shopping among roughly 115 active listings that had less competition in October than in September. When the winter closing figures come out, we will read any change in the median alongside October's thin contract month and the mix of homes that closed.

The pending line and the new-listing line will show the turn first. If falling rates bring buyers back, the ratio of contracts to new listings will move up from about 48 per 100 before any median does.

Questions We Hear About These Numbers

Did Bainbridge home prices rise 20% this year? The October 2026 median rose 19.67% from October 2025. The house-only median rose 10.02% over the same window, and five condos, all higher-end sales, pushed the combined figure up further. One month's median on this island is a small sample of whichever homes closed.

Is Bainbridge now a buyer's market? In October 2026, Bainbridge had 3.38 months of inventory, up from 2.15 in September. That is close to Kitsap County's 3.23 and below the 4.41 for the whole NWMLS service area. Buyers had more months of choice in October than in any of the three months before it. How much room there is to negotiate on a specific home depends on how that home compares with recent sales of similar homes.

When will November's figures come out? NWMLS published the October breakouts in early November, with its release dated November 5. November's figures should follow on a similar schedule in early December.

If you would like to compare a specific home with Bainbridge's recent sales of similar homes, The Agency Bainbridge Island can go through the comparable sales and current pending activity with you. Schedule a private consultation, and we will start with the homes you are already considering.

Work With Us

The Agency Bainbridge Island delivers top local expertise with a breadth of experience from an esteemed national brand to all clientele; from residential, new development, commercial, destination resorts and wherever you want to call home. Our brokers are dedicated to treating everyone like family and where luxury is an experience and not a price point.